Rejecting and Responding to a Low Insurance Settlement Offer

Rejecting and Responding to a Low Insurance Settlement Offer

signing contractFor those of us who are fans of legal dramas on television, the idea of going to court over a personal injury lawsuit may seem exciting — and a little nerve-wracking. In reality, the vast majority of personal injury cases are settled outside of court. This makes it incredibly important that your Long Island personal injury lawyer have top notch negotiation skills.

In most cases, the insurance company will start by offering you a low amount in the hopes that you will accept it. This is just the opening offer in what should be a series of negotiations designed to get you the money that you deserve.

The Steps of a Personal Injury Case

The Insurance Company Contacts You

In a typical personal injury case, after a person has suffered an injury, he or she will be contacted by an insurance company. The injured party may choose to cooperate with the insurance company to obtain a settlement, or consult with a Long Island personal injury lawyer about their rights and options.

Retaining an Attorney

By retaining an attorney, an injured person can determine if they are entitled to more compensation than what the insurance company is offering. A Long Island personal injury lawyer will thoroughly investigate the case, analyze the law, and draft a demand letter.

The Demand Letter

This letter will include the facts of the case, the legal basis for the claim, and the amount of damages claimed. The damages may include items such as medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and future medical treatment.

The Insurance Company’s Investigation

After a demand letter is sent, the insurance company will perform its own investigation. It will then reply with an offer to settle the case. The parties will negotiate back and forth until a final settlement is achieved. 95 to 96% of personal injury cases settle before trial. In rare cases, the case will go to trial, where a jury will either find for the plaintiff (the injured party) and award damages, or find for the defendant.

Responding to a Low Settlement Offer

The initial settlement offer made by many insurance companies is often very low. There are many reasons why this may happen. The claims adjuster may conclude that you were partially at fault for your injuries, or that your injuries were simply not as serious as what you claimed in your demand letter. Whatever the case may be, remember that this initial settlement offer is just the start of negotiations.

Insurance companies know that when victims of accidents receive their first settlement offer, they are often in difficult financial circumstances. They may have been out of work for weeks or months, and have significant medical bills. Many victims are eager to accept the first settlement offer that comes their way — even if it is lower than what they deserve for their injuries.

The job of the insurance company is not to make sure that you get the compensation that you deserve for your injuries. Insurance companies are for-profit businesses. They want to protect their bottom line — and that means offering you less money than you are rightfully owed.

When you receive an initial or low settlement offer, take the time to analyze the letter. Review the reasons given by the insurance company for the low settlement amount. A skilled Long Island personal injury lawyer can respond to each of the points made by the claims adjuster, and reiterate your position as to why you deserve compensation.

Next, focus on why you deserve a higher settlement offer. List the reasons why you are owed more compensation than what has been offered. Include a demand for more money (a higher settlement offer).

This will serve to reject the insurance company’s low settlement offer and to make a counteroffer. Your counteroffer should be lower than what you asked for in your initial demand letter to show that you are willing to compromise — but not so low that you do not have room to negotiate.

These types of negotiations may go back and forth for several weeks or months. An experienced Long Island personal injury lawyer can use the facts of your case plus awards from other personal injury cases to build a strong argument for settling at a desirable amount. For example, if a similar car accident case resulted in a jury award of $500,000, then a settlement amount of $450,000 will seem reasonable.

Work with a Long Island Personal Injury Lawyer

If you have been injured in any type of accident, working with a Long Island personal injury lawyer can help you get the money that you deserve for your injuries. Insurance companies do not want to just hand over money to you; it often requires aggressive negotiation for you to get fair compensation.

The attorneys Siler & Ingber have devoted their practice to representing victims of all types of accidents. We represent clients on a contingency fee basis, which means that we never charge a fee unless we recover money for you. To learn more or to schedule a free initial consultation, contact us today at 877-718-6079, or reach out online anytime.

Share this post



PROMOTION PERIOD: The Siler & Ingber Mineola MegaStar Contest begins on March 20, 2023 at 12:00 am ET and
ends on May 1, 2023 at 11:59 PM ET.

ELIGIBILITY: To be eligible, a MegaStar must be a legal U.S. resident at least 16 years of age as of date of
Nomination. A Mineola MegaStar is defined as a person who lives or works in Mineola and is admired or idealized for their courage, dedication, outstanding achievements, or noble qualities. By participating, Entrants agree to be
bound by the official rules. Sponsors reserve the right to verify and determine eligibility in their sole discretion.

TO PARTICIPATE: During the Promotion Period, Siler & Ingber will accept from the members of the public (herein, the “Nominators”) nominations of Eligible Entrants (Mineola Megastars) who live or works in Mineola. Nominations may be entered by visiting and completing the online form and essay submission or by emailing photo and essay to during the Promotion Period to receive one (1) entry. Essay must not exceed 500 words. Acceptable essay formats are word documents or pdf ONLY. Nominations submitted without all required information or after the Promotion Period will be disregarded.
Online submissions must be received by May 1, 2023 at 11:59 PM ET to be eligible. All entries become the exclusive property of Siler & Ingber and will not be acknowledged or returned.

ESSAY: During the promotion period, an Entrant can nominate a Mineola MegaStar for the contest by submitting a
photo and essay. The essay must describe why the individual should be chosen as the award winner, including how the individual demonstrates some or all of the following qualifications:

1) an inspiring example to others by helping make Mineola a better place to live (through volunteerism, extra-curricular actives, special projects, giving back, etc.)

2) going above and beyond to aid a friend, family member, stranger or community in a time of need; and/or

3) love of profession and desire, determination and diligence to help outside of normal job responsibilities. The essay must be in English and no more than 500 words. All information provided must be truthful, accurate and complete. An Entrant cannot nominate more than one Hero.

Submitted Materials: Each essay must satisfy all the following submission requirements the Submission


· The essay must be the original creation of Entrant.

· The essay must not portray any recognizable individual without their prior consent, including consent from the

· Entrant must either own all rights to the essay or otherwise have the right to submit the essay in the contest and to provide the rights to Sage Surfaces as set forth herein.

· The essay must not infringe any third party’s intellectual property rights.

· The essay may not contain illegal, indecent, obscene, pornographic, or sexually explicit content, or otherwise offensive material or inappropriate content such as aberrational behavior, graphic violence, drug abuse, or nudity.

· The essay must not promote bigotry, racism, hatred or harm against any group or individual or discrimination based on race, gender, religion, nationality, disability, sexual orientation or age.

· The essay must be non-defamatory and must not invade any third party’s right of privacy or publicity.

· The essay must otherwise be appropriate for publication or broadcast or display on a general interest website.

By submitting an essay, each Entrant represents and warrants that the essay meets all of the submission
requirements and that the distribution, reproduction, display and any other uses of any part of the essay by Siler & Ingber as permitted herein will not infringe any third-party rights. Each Entrant further agrees to indemnify and hold Siler & Ingber harmless from and against any and all claims, demands, damages, costs, liabilities and causes of action of whatsoever nature that are based upon or arise out of any breach by such Entrant of such warranties or representations made by contestant or of these official rules.

By submitting an essay, Entrant grants to Siler & Ingber a non-exclusive, perpetual, world-wide, royalty-free license (and waives all moral rights in and to the essay) to display or otherwise use the essay in connection with this promotion and as set forth herein. If Siler & Ingber determines, in its sole discretion and at any time during the promotion period, that any nomination violates the submission requirements, is otherwise unsuitable, offensive, or in poor taste, or violates these official rules, Siler & Ingber reserves the right to remove and disqualify the essay. Siler & Ingber retains sole
discretion as to whether any nomination satisfies the submission requirements and the official rules.

WINNER SELECTION: For the entry period, a panel of judges will select potential Mineola Megastar finalists based on the compelling nature of the essay based on the criteria set forth herein. Top 5 entries will be announced on May 10, 2023. We will post the top 5 on social media. Final winner announced May 15, 2023. Award Ceremony for Mineola MegaStar will take place on May 19, 2023.

WINNER NOTIFICATION AND RELEASES: We will attempt to notify potential winners via telephone and/or email. If a potential winner: (a) does not respond within 48 hours of initial notification attempt; (b) is not in compliance with these official rules, (c) does not meet the eligibility requirements, (d) declines the prize, he or she will be disqualified, and an alternate winner will be selected by applying the criteria set forth above.
PRIZES: There is 1 Mineola MegaStar. Winner will receive a $500 Cash Prize.

PUBLICITY AND MARKETING: Submission of a nomination in the contest constitutes permission to Siler & Ingber to use Entrants name, identity, title, likeness, distinctive appearance, physical likeness, image, portrait, picture, photograph (whether still or moving), screen persona, voice, vocal style, statements, gesture, mannerism, personality, performance characteristic, biographical data, signature, social media handles and identities, and any other indicia or imitation of identity or likeness for purposes of advertising and trade, in any medium, without further notice, approval, or compensation, unless prohibited by law.

PRIZE RESTRICTIONS: No transfer, assignment, sale, duplication, cash redemption or substitution of Prize (or portion of Prize) is permitted, except by Sponsors, which reserve the right to substitute a Prize (or applicable portion of Prize) with one of comparable or greater value, as determined by Sponsors. Sponsors are not responsible for and will not replace a lost or stolen Prize or any component thereof. All Prize details are at Sponsors’ sole and absolute discretion. Non-compliance with these Official Rules may result in disqualification and, at Sponsors’ sole discretion, the awarding of Prize to an alternate winner.


Do I Have A Case

    Skip to content